Slate Roofing Contractor Serving Atlanta, GA

Natural and Synthetic Slate Roof Repair and Replacement 

What Is Slate Roofing?

Quarried Stone, and the Synthetics Built to Match It

Slate roofing is quarried metamorphic stone split into thin shingles, and it outlasts nearly everything else you can put on a roof. Around metro Atlanta it turns up on historic homes, churches, and civic buildings, including the Arthur M. Blank Family Foundation headquarters and Decatur City Hall, both of which KTM Roofing re-roofed in slate.

Roofing slate is graded under ASTM C406, the international standard for roofing slate. Grade S1 carries an expected service life of more than 75 years, S2 runs 40 to 75 years, and S3 runs 20 to 40. Almost all slate installed on new North American roofs is S1, and S1 roofs frequently pass 100 years. Ask any slate roofer for the quarry and the grade before you sign anything.

Natural slate is also heavy, and most Atlanta homes were framed for asphalt shingles. Converting to natural slate means a structural evaluation first. That is exactly the gap synthetic slate was built to fill, which is why we install both.

Benefits of a Slate Roof

Why Slate Roofing Still Sets the Standard 

Grade S1 slate is rated for more than 75 years and routinely exceeds a hundred. Slate roofs are often salvaged and reinstalled on a second building, which is not a claim any other roofing material can make.

Slate is stone. It does not burn, melt, or release fumes, and it carries a Class A fire rating, the highest classification available for a roof covering. Synthetic slate from DaVinci reaches the same Class A rating with standard underlayment.

Quality roofing slate has a very low absorption rate, which is what keeps it from spalling through freeze-thaw cycles. Slate sheds water rather than holding it, and it does not rot, warp, curl, or shed granules the way organic and asphalt materials do.

The color of natural slate is the mineral content of the stone, not a coating. Unfading varieties look the same in year eighty as they did on day one, so a repair blends instead of announcing itself.

Slate roofing needs periodic roof inspection and occasional flashing work, not treatment or cleaning cycles. Most owners spend more attention on the copper and the underlayment than on the slate itself.

KTM slate roof home project
KTM slate roofing project

Signs Your Slate Roof Needs Repair or Replacement

The Slate Usually Outlasts Everything Holding It Up

Slate is brittle. It resists weathering for a century but chips and cracks under sharp impact, including hail and foot traffic from anyone who does not know how to walk it. Below the slate, the fasteners, flashing, and underlayment are on a much shorter clock. Watch for these:

A slipped or broken slate leaves the underlayment exposed to direct sun and rain. Individual slates are replaceable, so this is a slate roof repair and not a replacement, as long as it gets addressed.

Galvanized fasteners fail decades before the slate does. Rust staining below the slate line usually means the nails are corroding, and that is a system-wide problem rather than a spot fix.

Valleys, chimneys, and wall intersections are where slate roofs leak. Copper and lead-coated copper flashing last the longest; anything lighter becomes the weak point long before the stone does.

Slate that is powdering, flaking, or splitting along its layers has reached the end of its service life. This shows up on softer S2 and S3 material well before it appears on S1.

Water inside the house with no visible damage above almost always means the underlayment or flashing has gone, not the slate. A tear-off-and-relay reuses your existing slate over new underlayment and copper.

Types of Slate Roofing We Install

Natural Quarried Slate and Composite Alternatives

Natural Quarried Slate Vermont and Appalachian roofing slate

Vermont and New York quarries supply most of the natural slate installed in the Southeast, in grays, blacks, greens, purples, and reds, in both unfading and semi-weathering varieties. We specify Grade S1 material and install it the way slate has to be installed: copper or stainless fasteners, copper or lead-coated copper flashing, and two nails per slate set to hang rather than clamp. 

DaVinci Roofscapes Composite slate molded from virgin polymer

DaVinci molds its slate tiles from virgin resin with UV and thermal stabilizers rather than recycled feedstock, a deliberate choice the company makes for batch consistency. DaVinci slate carries a Class A fire rating with standard underlayment, a UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating, and a 110 mph wind rating, with more than fifty standard colors that can be blended.

EcoStar Composite slate from post-industrial recycled rubber and plastic

EcoStar builds its slate tiles from recycled EPDM rubber and TPO plastic. Traditional Slate is a quarter-inch tile in multiple widths and designer shapes; Niagara Slate is a five-eighths-inch enhanced shadow line whose cavity-back design cuts roof load by up to twenty percent. Both carry UL 2218 Class 4 impact resistance and are available with fifty-year warranty coverage. 

Brava Composite slate with through-tile Colorcast pigment

Brava’s Old World Slate reproduces the depth of quarried slate at a fraction of the weight. Its Colorcast mineral-infusion process runs pigment through the full thickness of every tile, so a replacement tile installed years later matches instead of standing out. Brava backs its slate with a fifty-year limited warranty and a Class 4 impact rating.

Slate Roofing FAQs

Common Questions From Atlanta Property Owners

Under ASTM C406, Grade S1 slate carries an expected service life of more than 75 years, and many S1 roofs pass a century. The underlayment, fasteners, and flashing beneath it do not last that long, which is why a slate roof is typically relaid once or twice across the life of the stone.

Not as a new order. Buckingham Slate ended production and is selling off remaining roofing inventory by piece count. If you own a Buckingham roof, matching material now comes from salvage, and we source it where we can. Where a match is not available, we will walk you through the closest alternatives rather than mixing in something that will read wrong from the street. 

For natural slate on a home framed for asphalt shingles, usually yes. We evaluate the structure before quoting. If reinforcement is not practical, composite slate from DaVinci, EcoStar, or Brava installs on standard framing and gets you the same look. 

Natural slate weathers extremely well but is brittle under sharp impact, and hail can crack it. Individual slates are replaceable. If hail is your primary concern, the Class 4 impact rating on composite slate is the stronger answer, and it may qualify for an insurance discount. 

Composite polymer, though the formulation is not the same from brand to brand. DaVinci molds its tiles from virgin resin with UV and thermal stabilizers, a deliberate choice for batch consistency. EcoStar builds from up to 80 percent post-industrial recycled rubber and plastic. Brava uses recycled polymer with its Colorcast mineral pigment run through the full thickness of the tile. All three install on standard framing, which is the practical difference from quarried stone.

Full roof replacements include a written, transferable 12-year workmanship warranty from KTM, alongside the manufacturer’s material warranty on composite products. We handle the manufacturer registration paperwork after final payment. 

KTM slate roofing project
KTM slate roofing project

Why We Install DaVinci, EcoStar, and Brava

Three Composites That Solve Different Problems 

Synthetic slate is not one product. The three manufacturers we install make genuinely different material choices, and the right one depends on your roof.

DaVinci uses virgin resin on purpose, arguing that variability in recycled feedstock undermines a fifty-year product. EcoStar takes the opposite position and builds from up to eighty percent post-industrial recycled rubber and plastic, which makes it the choice when a project is chasing sustainability credit. Brava’s advantage is Colorcast, its through-tile mineral pigment, which matters most on roofs likely to need repairs decades out.

All three land in the same place on the thing that drives most conversions: weight. Composite slate installs on standard framing with no structural reinforcement, which removes the engineering step that natural slate requires on a house built for shingles. We walk the roof, evaluate the structure, and tell you which of those two conversations you are actually in.

Natural Slate vs. Synthetic Slate

The Structural Question Usually Decides It

Natural slate is heavy. Most Atlanta homes were framed for asphalt shingles, so putting stone on one starts with a structural evaluation. Composite slate installs on the framing you already have.

Natural Quarried Slate Composite (Synthetic) Slate
Weight and structure Heavy. On a home framed for asphalt shingles, a structural evaluation comes first, and reinforcement is often required before installation. Installs on standard framing in most residential applications, with no substructure modification.
Expected service life Grade S1 material carries an expected service life of more than 75 years under ASTM C406, and S1 roofs frequently pass a century. Manufacturer coverage runs to 50 years and beyond. Shorter than S1 stone, considerably longer than asphalt.
Fire rating Class A. Slate is noncombustible stone. Varies by product. DaVinci is Class A with standard underlayment. EcoStar slate is Class C. Brava is Class C standard and reaches Class A with a specific underlayment assembly.
Impact resistance Not impact rated. Brittle under hail and foot traffic, though individual slates are replaceable. UL 2218 Class 4, the highest impact classification, across all three lines we install. May qualify for an insurance discount.
Repair and color matching Color is the mineral content of the stone, so unfading varieties hold. Matching a discontinued quarry means sourcing salvage. Replacement tiles match from current stock. Brava runs Colorcast pigment through the full tile thickness so a later repair does not read differently from the street.
Warranty Color is the mineral content of the stone, so unfading varieties hold. Matching a discontinued quarry means sourcing salvage. Replacement tiles match from current stock. Brava runs Colorcast pigment through the full tile thickness so a later repair does not read differently from the street.

Why Choose KTM Roofing for Slate 

Raising Roofing Standards in Atlanta Since 1984 

Slate is the least forgiving material in residential roofing. It cracks if you walk it wrong, it leaks if the flashing is detailed wrong, and the fasteners have to outlive the stone. There is no shortcut and no way to learn it on someone’s house.

Tim McLoughlin founded KTM Roofing on specialty materials in 1984, and slate has been core work ever since. Our slate projects include the Arthur M. Blank Family Foundation headquarters, installed in Buckingham slate with lead-coated copper flashing and copper nails, and the historic slate roof at Decatur City Hall. We also work in tile, wood shake, metal, and asphalt, so we have no reason to steer you toward slate if your roof does not call for it.

You get a written estimate before anything starts, a crew that has done this before, and an invoice that arrives after the work is finished.

KTM side of slate roof project